Degustation, NYC 2

April 30, 2013

Degustation has been a favorite of some New York foodies since its opening in 2007. It gets a 28 (the 2nd highest) food rating in Zagat, but faint praise in other media. I dined there in 2009; my reaction was mixed, but I concluded: “I would be happy to go back … as I could sense the talent of the chef.” Well, the chef has changed several times since then, but Linda and I went for dinner on April 21, 2013.

We were seated by the corner of the counter near the entrance. The restaurant was originally designed with a Japanese-style counter and retains that seating format. There are two cooks who have a grill, a plancha, a deep-fryer etc at their disposal. Cooked ingredients are then passed to the plating chef, who artfully prepares the plates with the many garnishes and sauces she has nearby.
degustation 004 (480x195)

As the plating station was right in front of us, we could see every dish being assembled.
degustation 015 (480x244)

On sitting down we ordered glasses of Cordoníu Cava Brut NV.  This refreshing sparkler was followed by a bottle of 2008 Pesquera Reserva, Ribera del Duero, which was excellent.
degustation 007 (391x440)

There is a fairly limited à la carte menu of small plates plus our choice, a seven-course tasting menu. The tasting menu dishes were not taken from the à la carte menu; they were described to us as they were served with music and conversation in the background; some are quite complex making the descriptions hard to grasp and remember. I have presented my version of what we heard, saw and tasted below.

The amuse-bouche was a Virginia oyster with mustard seed and lemon.
degustation 005 (440x301)
The seasoning was restrained and the oyster very nice.

The first menu course was chunk of octopus braised in red wine and grilled. It was accompanied by pickled carrot curls, a pea shoot, a Marcona almond and a scoop of red onion confit.
degustation 009 (470x323)
The one piece of octopus was very good, but frustratingly small, particularly with so many garnishes.


A grilled white asparagus stalk, coated with pumpernickel breadcrumbs, cut in half lengthwise; lemon thyme meringue wafers, pistachios, spinach purée underneath.
degustation 010 (480x196)
This dish was excellent. The garnishes were appropriate and understated, allowing the asparagus flavor, which had been enhanced by its grilling, to shine through.

A poached egg was dressed with a spoonful of bacon broth and then covered with crumbs of Funyun, Frito-Lay’s onion-flavored corn chip snack. A dab of paddlefish caviar was added on top.
degustation 012 (450x307)
Well, that is what I think they said to us, and to our neighbors when it was served to them. The egg was enjoyable and fun, but the industrial quality of the crumbs came through. Too bad they didn’t simply make their own flavored breadcrumbs.

Sautéed corvina from Panama covered with Riesling foam on top of cauliflower purée sauce.
degustation 014 (450x321)
The corvina had a surprisingly strong flavor, almost like mackerel and so it stood up to the saucing. Very nice.

Risotto with bacon, Hawaiian blue prawns, broccoli leaves, and arugula flowers on top.
degustation 017 (455x300)
The flavors were a good combination, but were not assertive. The texture was good.

Quail, lemon purée, swiss chard, small potatoes, cavatelli and red sorrel.
degustation 020 (480x364)
The quail meat on the bones was submerged by the many other ingredients.

The cheese plate featured a Manchego-like Spanish cheese with honey, thin wafers, cashews and red sorrel.
degustation 022 (480x216)

The pre-dessert had an orange gel cube, a mint leaf and reddish granules whose name I did not catch.
degustation 023 (450x230)


The dessert was “Bruléed French Toast, Smoked Maple Syrup.”
degustation 025 (440x249)
It seemed to be made of a bready custard. Very good.

We had a good time and enjoyed the cuisine. The ingredients were good and well prepared in a variety of styles and imaginative, well-conceived combinations, although I thought that the octopus and quail dishes were too complicated, submerging the main ingredient. The pace was fine, but I imagine that it slowed down as the restaurant filled up. Watching the plating and the other diners added to the interest.

To see my meal at Degustation in 2009 click here.

4 Responses to “Degustation, NYC 2”

  1. Sam Spektor Says:

    When are restaurants in America going to learn that pasta is not a vegetable!?

  2. Dear Mike,

    This reads like a fascinating culinary evening, but how would you describe the cuisine? I noticed you ordered Spanish wine and there is Spanish cheese, but the ingredients and the influence appear to come from all over the place.

  3. Alex Says:

    I enjoyed reading this review, as I dined myself there, long time ago. Too bad the industrial quality of the chips in that one dish with poached egg came through. I somehow like the idea of combining genuine fine dining ingredients with industrial elements. Pop-art of dining one might say. Cheers, Alex

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.